Stockertim Dictionary · Consulting
Initial hypothesis
Also called working hypothesis, starting hypothesis
In short
A provisional answer to the engagement question, written at the start to direct the analysis and then tested rather than defended.
- Intermediate
- Concept
- Checked
In detail
An initial hypothesis is a team's best guess at the answer before the evidence is in. Rather than collecting every possible fact and hoping an answer emerges, the team states early what it thinks is true, such as "margins fell mainly because of discounting in the online channel", and then designs the analysis to prove or disprove it.
Working this way saves time. Each hypothesis tells the team which data to request, which interviews to hold and which analyses to run first. Hypotheses are usually built on the branches of an issue tree, and each comes with a statement of what would have to be true for it to hold. Evidence that knocks one down is as valuable as evidence that supports it.
The danger is attachment. A team that becomes fond of its early answer may notice only supporting facts, a trap known as confirmation bias. Good practice is to write down in advance what would disprove the hypothesis, to look for that evidence first and to revise openly. The initial hypothesis is a tool for focus, not a conclusion.
In practice
On day two, a team writes three hypotheses for falling profits, lists the test for each and assigns analysts. By week three one is confirmed, one rejected and one replaced by a new idea from interviews.
Watch out
- A hypothesis must be testable; "the strategy is unclear" is too vague to prove or disprove.
- Presenting an untested hypothesis to the client as a finding damages trust.
Learn it properly
Official sources
- NIST/SEMATECH e-Handbook: What are statistical tests? · National Institute of Standards and Technology
- The AQuA Book: guidance on producing quality analysis for government · HM Treasury
Facts last checked on 3 November 2026.
Education, not advice: the Stockertim Dictionary explains what terms mean. It never recommends buying or selling anything.