Stockertim Dictionary · Audit and assurance
Supervisory review
Also called file review, review of working papers, engagement supervision
In short
The check by a more senior auditor that the work done supports the conclusions reached, the programme was completed and the evidence is properly recorded.
- Advanced
- Process
- Checked
In detail
Every audit engagement needs supervision. A supervisory review is the step in which a manager or senior auditor examines the working papers before conclusions are reported. The reviewer checks that each planned test was performed or the reason for omitting it is recorded, that the evidence supports each finding, that the overall rating is consistent with the findings, and that the file would let another experienced auditor follow the work.
Review happens at several points. Early review of the plan and programme catches scope problems before time is wasted. Review during fieldwork guides less experienced staff and catches weak evidence while there is still time to fix it. Final review before the draft report confirms that the conclusions are sound. Reviewers record their comments and how each was resolved.
Supervision is a core part of quality assurance. Professional standards require the chief audit executive to make sure engagements are properly supervised, and external quality assessments examine the evidence of review. Weak review is a frequent cause of findings that management can later disprove.
In practice
Audit software records sign-offs by preparer and reviewer for each working paper, with dated review notes that must be cleared before the report is issued.
Watch out
- A sign-off without evidence of real challenge is a weak review.
Learn it properly
Official sources
- Global Internal Audit Standards · The Institute of Internal Auditors
- ISA (UK) 220: Quality management for an audit of financial statements · Financial Reporting Council
Facts last checked on 3 November 2026.
Education, not advice: the Stockertim Dictionary explains what terms mean. It never recommends buying or selling anything.