Stockertim Dictionary · Consulting · Audit and assurance
Quality review
Also called quality assurance review, peer review, QA review
In short
A structured check of a deliverable by someone outside the working team, testing its logic, numbers and wording before the client sees it.
- Intermediate
- Process
- Checked
In detail
A quality review is a second pair of eyes on work before it goes out. The reviewer, often a senior colleague who has not been involved day to day, reads the deliverable as the client would and asks whether the answer is clear, whether the evidence supports it, whether the numbers are right and consistent, and whether anything could embarrass the client or the firm.
Reviews usually work at several levels. An analyst checks figures against the source data and the model; the manager checks that each page supports its title and the storyline holds; an independent reviewer challenges the conclusions and the risks. For models and analysis that inform important decisions, government guidance calls for proportionate quality assurance, with more scrutiny where the stakes and complexity are higher, and a record of what was checked.
Leaving review until the night before a deadline defeats its purpose, because there is no time to fix what it finds. Good teams schedule reviews into the plan, give reviewers the materials early and treat their comments as a normal part of the work rather than as criticism.
In practice
Two days before a board paper is sent, a partner from another team reviews it, finds that a savings figure on page four does not match the appendix, and asks for the model to be checked.
Watch out
- Proofreading is not a quality review; the logic and evidence must be tested too.
- A reviewer who helped write the work is not independent.
Learn it properly
Official sources
- The AQuA Book: guidance on producing quality analysis for government · HM Treasury
- Quality statistics in government · Government Analysis Function
Facts last checked on 3 November 2026.
Education, not advice: the Stockertim Dictionary explains what terms mean. It never recommends buying or selling anything.