Stockertim Dictionary · Advertising
Creative review
Also called creative reviews, work-in-progress review, creative approval
In short
A structured meeting in which creative work is judged against the brief, feedback is recorded and a decision is taken to approve, revise or stop.
- Intermediate
- Process
- Checked
In detail
A creative review is the formal checkpoint at which a client and an agency look at work in progress and decide what happens next. What makes it a review rather than a chat is its structure: the agreed brief as the yardstick, named people with authority to decide, written notes and a clear outcome before the meeting closes.
Useful feedback describes a problem and why it matters against the brief, for example that the audience may not grasp what the line means. Less useful feedback dictates a fix, such as rewording the line in a particular way, which sidelines the maker's skill and may not solve the problem at all. Personal taste counts only as a tie-breaker between options that already meet the brief.
Reviews are normally arranged in rounds, each with a purpose: first whether the concept is right, then whether the executions are right, then whether every detail is correct, including spellings, mandatories, legal lines and formats. The number of rounds and the approver at each stage are agreed before work begins. Late arrivals do the most damage: an approver who first sees the work at the final round can undo weeks of agreed decisions.
Between rounds the concept is restated unchanged, execution notes are actioned, and any note that would alter the concept is discussed openly with the decision-maker rather than quietly absorbed.
In practice
Agencies circulate the brief and the work before the meeting, present against the brief and send written notes and the decision within a day. Larger advertisers record each approval in a workflow system so every sign-off is traceable when the work reaches production and delivery.
Watch out
- A review that ends without a decision is only a discussion; each meeting closes with approve, revise or stop.
- A verbal approval given in passing is easily disputed later, so sign-offs are recorded in writing.
Learn it properly
Official sources
- Co-creation: working with diverse audiences · Government Communication Service
- OASIS: planning government communications · Government Communication Service
- Evaluate and learn: the Evaluation Cycle · Government Communication Service
Facts last checked on 3 November 2026.
Education, not advice: the Stockertim Dictionary explains what terms mean. It never recommends buying or selling anything.