Stockertim Dictionary · Audit and assurance
But-for analysis
Also called but-for test, but for analysis, counterfactual loss analysis
In short
A way of measuring a loss by comparing what would have happened without the wrongful event with what actually happened.
- Advanced
- Process
- Checked
In detail
When a party claims it has been harmed, the question is not simply what it earned but what it would have earned had the wrong not occurred. But-for analysis builds that alternative picture, often called the counterfactual or but-for scenario, and sets it against the actual results. The difference, after allowing for costs the claimant saved, is the loss attributable to the wrongful act.
Building the counterfactual is the hard part. Analysts use the business's own history before the event, budgets prepared at the time, the performance of comparable firms, market data and expert views on what would have changed anyway. They must separate the effect of the wrong from other causes, such as a recession, a new competitor or the claimant's own poor decisions, which would have hurt results regardless.
The method appears in contract claims, competition damages, intellectual property cases and fraud losses. Courts look closely at whether the assumptions are reasonable and supported, and whether the analyst has tested how sensitive the answer is to them.
Formula
Loss = but-for profit − actual profit
- but-for profit
- the profit the business would have made without the wrongful event
- actual profit
- the profit the business really made
Worked example
A supplier, Northgate Foods, breaks a contract and a café chain loses a key product line for a year. Before the breach the line earned steady margins, and the chain's other lines grew normally.
- But-for profit on the line, based on the prior year and normal growth: 120,000 × 1.05 = 126,000
- Actual profit on the line during the year: 46,000
- Loss: 126,000 − 46,000 = 80,000
The estimated loss is 80,000, before any deduction for costs the chain saved or any mitigation it should have made.
In practice
Forensic accountants present the but-for and actual figures side by side in a schedule, with the key assumptions listed so the court can adjust them. The opposing expert typically attacks the counterfactual, arguing for slower growth or other causes of the decline.
Watch out
- The counterfactual is an estimate, not a fact; small changes to growth or margin assumptions can move the answer a lot.
- Do not count a loss twice, for example as both lost profit and a lower business value.
Learn it properly
Official sources
- Damages · Legal Information Institute
Facts last checked on 3 November 2026.
Education, not advice: the Stockertim Dictionary explains what terms mean. It never recommends buying or selling anything.